Board Thread:Quest Board/@comment-33207690-20190729154154/@comment-33207690-20190731014953

I think one should the non-canon movie statement with a pinch of salt since instead of canon since the movie is not canon. While Nakaba is involved, mostly with the character designs im guessing, the script writer of the movie isn't Nakaba -  it's Makoto Uezu. It looks like she forgot Nakaba revealed it or maybe she wanted to have her say that to keep one of her appeals as a mysterious woman for the movie.

I would take the canon manga chapters, instead, seriously. Chpt 291 came out 3 months after that movie further stating that she's a human which coincides with what was said back in 191.

Either way, it looks like Nakaba fixed their mistake from the movie that he didn't catch otherwise Nakaba wouldn't have written Cusack stating that she was a human in that manga chapter. He wouldn't have had Cusack refer to her race at all. He wouldn't have done that if he wanted to keep it ambiguous. He did it to dispell that.

Whatever confusion there is from the non-canon movie its not ambiguous anymore since he had Cusack outright and clearly stated that she is a human afterwords. In-universe, there was no double meaning in Cusacks words or motive of Cusack trying to be secretive about her race especially when he had no shame or trouble in expressing his disgust at her race as a human. Merlin didn't even deny it, she was just looked smug and proud.

So two clear statements, written by Nakaba, about being human vs one ambiguous statement, written by Uezu, about being similar to Ban. I think the two clear ones from the canon manga is more relevant than the one ambiguous statement in the non-canon movie. There is more clarity than ambiguity.

The movie is non-canon so she basically and essentially never said that. That one ambiguous statement shouldn't override the other two statements overall or take precedent over both as it holds shaky grounds since its an ambiguous statement.

Chpt 291 is the new and updated/reconfirmation info on Merlins race so, while some may be confused, this is what he wrote in the end. I don't think our confusion on why that statement was said in the non-canon movie should take precedent in deciding that the new chpt 291 info is irrelevant or that it also automatically means ambiguous when it was a clear sentence or that the previous non-canon movie statement is more relevant than the new updated canon info and old canon info.

Chpt 291 is the new updated info and yes it should be put into the infobox regardless of the fans confusion or doubts that Nakaba is trying to be ambiguous with her race despite the very clear statements in the manga.

Yes, because Elizabeth is a Goddess and a human. When Elizabeth came back with her memories she classified herself as the princess and the goddess. She is basically a Goddess with a human body. Her soul as a Goddess is still there otherwise she wouldn't have Goddess powers.

Immortal isn't a race. Chandler did say that Ban is human. Ban himself stated that he is a human to Chandler. He just wasn't a "regular" human whose lifespan is finite.

He was, at face value, a human who gained eternal life and then lost it. A human being kept alive by a magic fountain is still a human, otherwise, Meliodas wouldn't be a demon because he has a curse on him.

Ban is still a human regardless. As of now, without the immortality, he is just one of the regular humans with the general lifespans.

Edit: lol, im turning this into too much of a debate. Im forgetting this is just a vote post. I thought there would be more people.