Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-4556650-20130716143338/@comment-3390396-20130720053302

'Tis not as catchy as "Fountain of Youth", is it? ;)

Yes, the cup itself appears to be the fountain, and the water inside it, the "magic" water. No logical person will steal a cup after drinking the magic water from it. And unless a cup is gargantuan enough to resemble an island that holds at least 500 humans, I will consider it an object. So... the water's an item, of course, and we'll keep the cup as an item too.