Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-4556650-20130716143338/@comment-3544775-20130720113139

Did I say we should follow and work on the assumption that there may be small mistake?

The cup do not only holds the water, it creates it (that's why it's probably called fountain). As you can see, the water is gushing out of it and from the spilling, it created a small lake and looks like a small fountain. Yet it seems it always remains full, since it didn't fully spilled when Elaine tilted it (only small drops were spilled). So we don't know if the only way to remove the water is by drinking it all or there is some other way. And after that we don't know even more of what happens with the cup. Can the water continue to gush out or it dries because it was drunked? And also that spilled water around it, can still do its magic and make someone immortal? If I have to guess, it's no, but we can't confirm it at all.